Old·ham \ˈōl-dəm\ – The Oldham name has been synonymous with the Indianapolis community and the insurance industry since the mid 1950’s. An Oldham has positively impacted people in the community either via service contributions and/or meeting insurance and financial needs for over 60 years.

The Oldham Insurance Agency has been in existence since 2012, when Donald Oldham, III left an insurance agency with an exclusive carrier and started an independent agency believing that people should be able to have options when they find an insurance agent they trust and believe in. He believed that giving his clients multiple options was the best way to ensure they could be clients for life.

Paul Clayton, Jr.

Paul Clayton Jr.

Principal Agent

Paul, from Indianapolis, is an experienced sales consultant, with customer service, product and service sales, sales management, and account management. Having worked for Verizon for 8 years in several capacities, his experience makes him primed and well prepared to be an integral part of the Oldham Insurance Agency. Paul is father of three young girls, Nia, Zola, and Anya with his wife Sarah. He is the drummer for the music ministry at his church, Solid Word and has played with several groups and bands over the years. Paul is member of the 100 Black Men of Indianapolis, a service organization focused on mentoring and helping youth to be the leaders of tomorrow.


Phone: 317-464-7444

Email: paul@oldhaminsured.com

Don Oldham, III

Donald Oldham, III, CIC

Principal Agent

Donald is from Indianapolis, a proud graduate of North Central High School where he starred on the North Central Soccer, state champion team. He holds a B.S. in finance from Clark H. Byrum School of Business at Marian University, where he played collegiate soccer as well. Donald worked as an insurance producer for an exclusive insurance agency right out of college prior to starting Oldham Insurance. He was under the tutelage of his father, Donald Oldham, Jr. who has over 30 years of industry experience. Donald holds his Certified Insurance Counselor designation, which is one the most prestigious designations in the insurance industry. In his downtime, he enjoys playing and coaching soccer, playing golf, and reading.



Phone: 317-328-4444

Email: don3@oldhaminsured.com

4747 W. 71st Street
Indianapolis IN 46268

Latest Tweets Latest Tweets

Back to Top